Argos Limited Saves $180K by Migrating from HP ALM to TestRail - TestRail

Argos Limited Saves $180K by
Migrating from HP ALM to TestRail

Summary: Migrating from HP ALM to TestRail

By replacing HP ALM with TestRail, not only did the QA team at Argos Limited realize significant cost savings. With TestRail, Argos was able to modernize and expand its testing processes, break down silos between developers, QA, and key business stakeholders, and ultimately focus more on what matters most to their organization and customers: deploying new releases on time & bug-free.

The Challenge

If you want to compete with Amazon, you had better come ready for a fight.

Argos Limited started as a high street catalog store in the early 1970’s. Today, as part of the Sainsbury Group, Argos operates nearly 900 physical stores across the UK, and has become the UK’s third-largest online retailer.

E-commerce has become increasingly important to Argos’ success, with over 1 billion visits to their online store in the last year alone. But margins are tight and competition stiff.

For Argos QA Service Manager David Brown, the hybrid of online plus brick and mortar channels means supporting a “big, weighty integrated system” that includes everything from finance systems running on mainframe servers to firmware on point-of-sale devices and high-volume websites.

As more and more business has shifted online over the last five years, Argos has gone through a process of transitioning from waterfall-driven development to an agile approach. Despite the increase in complexity of the technical systems they test, the quality team at Argos has simultaneously had to keep costs as low as possible to help Argos compete against online giants like Amazon.

In response, the technical testing and QA team at Argos needed to evolve their testing approach to support both the old, mainframe-based infrastructure (where a lot of testing is manual) as well as new micro service-based webapps (where changes are more frequent, release pipelines are built around CI/CD, and a lot of testing can be automated).

It also meant finding a more cost-effective, easier-to-use tool to manage their testing efforts.

Argos’ previous test management tool, HP ALM, was “bulky, confusing, and more importantly, expensive,” according to David. As the organization worked through a company-wide digital transformation initiative over the last few years, David was charged with finding a tool that could save the team money while continuing to meet all of their test management requirements.

  1. Like many IT teams, the QA and Dev teams at Argos use Atlassian Jira for project management, so compatibility between their testing tool and Jira was important.
  2. The testing tool needed to be able to handle a wide variety of testing frameworks and use cases, from regression and functional testing to user acceptance and integration testing. It also needed to be able to handle Argos’ massive test case repository, which numbers in the tens of thousands across their various technical systems.
  3. The tool also needed to be easy to use and easy to onboard with. Argos’ QA team is made up of a variety of functional roles, from embedded software engineers in test to automation engineers and business-facing manual testers, and whatever new test management tool they adopted had to support each of their users’ workflows and styles.

Most importantly, the tool needed to be cost-effective and well supported.

"TestRail allowed us to hit the ground running."
- David Brown, Argos Limited
signal_cellular_4_bar

The Solution

After doing some research, comparing various vendors and completing a few trials, it became clear that TestRail was the right choice to support Argos’ test management efforts moving into the 2020s.

As David explained: “TestRail allowed us to hit the ground running.” 

1. Usability

The first and most notable difference between TestRail and HP ALM was the actual user interface. “ALM was very cluttered, while TestRail was clean and made it easy to get to where you needed to go—a real tester-friendly tool.”

2. Features

TestRail’s Milestones feature gave David’s team an easy way to plan, execute, and track their testing efforts across multiple test runs all related to the same, cross-system release. Easy-to-read pie charts help David’s team get a pulse on the progress of testing at a glance, with more customized and extensive reporting available for more significant retrospective requests.

TestRail also gave each of the different teams spread across Argos’ systems the flexibility to implement the workflow and settings they needed to be successful across a wide variety of test types (from performance testing to automated testing to user acceptance testing). Some teams use the TestRail API trigger automated tests and post test results so they can track the status of all of their testing from a single source of truth.

3. Cost

Most importantly, by switching to TestRail, David was able to save his QA team more than $180,000 a year. 

As David put it, the savings from TestRail “was a significant amount—you can do a bit with that. That’s 4-5 extra heads on the team.”

The Result

TestRail was a strategic investment for Argos’ QA team, providing a robust tool to ensure high-quality software releases across an incredibly complex system. But what was the ultimate reason TestRail was the right tool for the job? It did all this while giving David and his colleagues more budget flexibility and allowing them to be more agile in their response in the rapidly-changing landscape of their business.

play_arrow

On-Demand Webinar: Test Management in TestRail

Learn some approaches and best practices for test management with TestRail. Presented by Simon Knight, TestRail Product Manager.

The best in the world use TestRail test management

"TestRail fits in perfectly to our test management needs. Thank you for the great tool and great support."
– Kalyan Balasa, Program Management, Continental
signal_cellular_4_bar
"I compared different tools and TestRail was much better than others. TestRail works really fast, has a clean, simple UI, a really good workflow, and intuitive test case management."
– Gleb Budko, Autodesk, Inc.
signal_cellular_4_bar
"TestRail has greatly improved our acceptance phase and reporting. Thanks for the great product and incredible support."
– Stan Kaštánek, Software Architect, Airbus Helicopters
signal_cellular_4_bar
"TestRail is exactly what our team was looking for. TestRail has the perfect blend of design and functionality."
– Gary Chan, Lead Test Engineer, Citrix Systems, Inc
signal_cellular_4_bar

Try TestRail for Free

Try TestRail in the cloud for quick and secure access, or download for your own server.

TestRail is a leader in Test Management on G2
TestRail is a leader in Test Management on G2
TestRail is a leader in Enterprise Software Testing on G2
TestRail is a leader in Enterprise Software Testing on G2

Outstanding customer satisfaction

Highest-rated: TestRail is the leader in the annual 2019 G2 Grid for Test Management, with the best ratings for customer satisfaction and ease of use, as well as the Spring 2020 G2 Grid and the Fall 2020 G2 Grid.*

Most popular: According to the 2019 DevTestOps Landscape Survey, TestRail is the most popular test management tool in the industry.

For more independently-verified research and reviews, visit the TestRail page at G2, TechValidate, or Capterra.

* G2 identifies leading solutions in a market segment based on market presence and customer satisfaction. To determine market presence, G2 uses a combination of 15 metrics about a vendor and product such as the number of employees, web and social presence, and growth. The customer satisfaction rating is based on an analysis of reviews submitted by real, verified users.